Blogs

As a business owner, you've probably faced moments where you knew things could be done better, faster, or more efficiently. The question then becomes: how do you approach this need for change? Do you go for business process optimisation (BPO) and tweak your existing workflows, or do you take the bolder route of business process reengineering (BPR) and rethink everything from scratch?

It is important to understand the key differences between these two approaches, when to use each, and why reengineering could be the more effective option in certain situations. We’ll also dive into real-world examples, and by the end, you’ll have a clear sense of which strategy fits your business best.

What is Business Process Reengineering (BPR)?

Business Process Reengineering, or BPR, is a radical approach to improving the way your business operates. Unlike process optimisation, where you’re making small adjustments to improve efficiency, BPR is about tearing down the existing processes and starting from scratch. It's a total redesign of how your business functions.

The goal is dramatic improvements in productivity, customer satisfaction, cost-effectiveness, and time-to-market. It’s not just about making things a little better—it’s about rethinking how work gets done to achieve breakthrough results.

For example, instead of improving your existing order fulfilment process by 10%, BPR aims to redesign the entire system to cut down order delivery times by 50% or more. The focus isn’t on gradual improvement but on reinvention.

The Nitty-Gritty of BPR

Let’s dig deeper into what BPR really entails. When you take on a reengineering project, you’re typically:

1. Starting with a blank slate: Forget the way things have always been done. The goal is to rethink processes from the ground up.
2. Focusing on key processes: Not all processes in your business will need to be reengineered, but those that are mission-critical—like customer service, order fulfilment, or production—are ripe for BPR.
3. Leveraging technology: This is where modern tools like ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) and RPA (Robotic Process Automation) come in. These technologies help automate repetitive tasks, integrate data across systems, and improve productivity by eliminating manual bottlenecks.
4. Streamlining workflows: BPR aims to simplify. You might eliminate entire steps in a process, automate others, and consolidate roles to make the process as streamlined as possible.

When to Consider Business Process Reengineering

BPR isn't for the faint of heart. It's a bold, disruptive approach to change, and it's usually employed in specific situations:

1. Severe inefficiencies: If your processes are so outdated or broken that incremental changes won't cut it, BPR is the answer.
2. New business models: If you're shifting to a new business model—say, from a brick-and-mortar retail store to an e-commerce model—you need to rethink everything, and BPR is the way to do that.
3. Major technological changes: If you're implementing a new ERP system, adopting AI-driven tools, or undergoing a digital transformation, reengineering your processes to match the capabilities of your new tech is a must.

Business Process Optimisation: A Conservative Approach

On the other hand, you have Business Process Optimisation (BPO). This approach is about refinement—making small, manageable changes to your existing workflows.

Imagine you’ve been fulfilling orders the same way for years. Things run relatively smoothly, but you know there are small tweaks you could make to improve productivity. BPO focuses on identifying these inefficiencies and correcting them, whether it's by automating part of the process, retraining staff, or introducing a better workflow.

When to Use Business Process Optimisation

While BPR is revolutionary, BPO is evolutionary. It’s perfect when your processes are mostly functional, but you need them to run a bit better. Here are some situations where optimisation makes sense:

1. Processes are mostly efficient: If you’re seeing good results but know there's room for improvement, you’re a candidate for BPO.
2. Low risk tolerance: Some businesses can’t afford to take the risks that come with BPR. In this case, making small adjustments is the safer bet.
3. Budget constraints: BPR often requires significant investment in time, resources, and new technologies. BPO can be a more cost-effective option for businesses with tighter budgets.

A Real-World Example: Ford Motor Company

Let’s take a look at a verified example of BPR. In the 1980s, Ford faced a major inefficiency in its accounts payable department. They had hundreds of employees manually processing invoices. Instead of tweaking the process by hiring more staff or optimising individual tasks, Ford took a BPR approach and redesigned the entire system, using automation and ERP to eliminate most of the manual work. The result? They reduced the number of employees from 500 to 125, saving millions of dollars.

On the flip side, imagine a mid-sized retailer. They realise their warehouse management process is slowing them down, but overall, they’re still profitable. Instead of reengineering the entire warehouse system, they choose to optimise by automating stock checks and introducing a new CRM (Customer Relationship Management) tool to improve order tracking. Their goal isn’t a radical overhaul, but incremental productivity improvements.

Scenario: A Manager's Decision

Let’s consider a hypothetical situation. You’re the operations manager at a mid-sized manufacturing firm. Your company has been growing steadily, but you’re starting to notice inefficiencies in your production line. Orders are taking longer to fulfil, and your employees are bogged down with repetitive tasks.

Now, you have two choices:

1. Business Process Optimisation: You could look for ways to make small tweaks—maybe automating a few tasks with RPA or implementing some minor workflow changes.
2. Business Process Reengineering: Alternatively, you could go for a more radical solution. You could redesign the entire production process, possibly integrating a new ERP system that automates everything from inventory management to shipping.

Which do you choose? If your processes aren’t completely broken, you might go for BPO. But if the inefficiencies are severe and you're ready for a breakthrough, BPR might be the better choice.

Which Approach is Right for You?

At the end of the day, the decision between BPR and BPO comes down to the specific needs of your business. Are your processes broken beyond repair? Are you adopting new technology or shifting to a completely new business model? In that case, reengineering might be your best bet. But if you’re looking for more incremental improvements, and your processes are mostly functional, optimisation could get you the results you need with less risk.

Final Thoughts on Reengineering and Optimisation

Both BPR and BPO have their place in today’s fast-moving business environment. BPR is ideal for businesses looking to reinvent themselves, while BPO is perfect for those who just need to refine what’s already working. By taking a close look at your processes, you can determine which approach makes the most sense for your business.

And whether you’re planning to optimise or completely reengineer your workflows, remember that ERP, CRM, AI, and RPA tools can help drive those changes. These technologies, when used properly, will dramatically improve your productivity and allow you to better compete in today’s market.